Thank you very much for sharing and putting forth among our small body of believers some of your pain in watching a nation you love fall into bigotry and fear. I have no solutions to offer, there are none…only the realization that living in a nation such as ours…a nation with positive potential for good in the world…can lead us to the tempting but potentially idolatrous notion that nation-states can be good, when in-fact they cannot.
Followers of Jesus have been reaching for this sort of meaning in our nation-states for millennia, the idea that nations can do the work that that His People are called to do. Rabbi Saul/Paul makes it clear in his letter to the His People in Rome that nations are institutions empowered to restrain (individual) evil upon the pain of death (nationalized evil). When Constantine picked up his Sword back in the 4th century he set the pattern for the Institutional Church and it’s deference and willingness to be represented and empowered by nation-states…what we see now is a cyclical repeat of that “taking up of arms”. Constantine had a vision of the cross Jesus died upon, turned it into a sword and claimed it as a method of conquering the world (as he knew it). Our culture is simply a modern-day manifestation of this.
James Carroll, a defrocked Catholic Priest (I really like defrocked Catholic Priests!) had a lot to say about this in a book he named Constantine’s Sword; very interesting and informative. (For you dear sisters and brothers in Christ who are from the Catholic Tradition please be reminded that though in practice Catholicism is quite uncomfortable for me, I have deep respect for many Catholic Traditions and viewpoints…actually much of what I know I learned from a dear friend/professor, a Franciscan Priest from Croatia who’s deeply involved in the peace movement.) This most recent “travel ban” is an expression of Christian Primacy, in other words, it’s a dominance expression of our national religion (something that looks like Christianity and claims to be Christianity) over another religion it finds threatening (Islam).
We’ve adapted ourselves to this hateful and negative faith, but it bears no resemblance to the faith Jesus called us to live and love and teach. I’ll leave it to all of the prophetic sorts to determine whether this church is really the antichrist, or whether it’s actually the next leader of Russia or maybe a liberal Senator.
This syncretic form of Christianity has adapted itself to it’s political masters, right now they call themselves “conservative” but they could call themselves pretty much anything; political ideology is a meaningless construct in Jesus’ context…the party of “Love Your Neighbor” maybe?
For my own mental and emotional health I’ve deleted my Facebook account, I never could express myself very well there as most of my thoughts exceed the attention-span of the Facebook crowd…let alone Twitter’s 144 characters… I’ve spent more time reading and writing and thankfully, for what I do, very few people feel any sort of need to talk about politics…my mom sometimes tries to but I rebuff it in order to not upset her. I’ve found comfort in historical works, in fact one good one I’ve been slowly working through has to do with “Why Liberals Always Win the Culture Wars…” or something like that…and it’s gone through all of the different “culture wars” that people of national faith have fought in America…and it’s quite interesting and assuring.
Sensibility has been ruptured, and I think that there is some “danger” in speaking out against the current political regime, Jesus found that to be true…and it was the religious people that did him in…the secular folks didn’t really care so much. I don’t think that we have to be terribly fearful, just cautious in our own communities. I know that an aspect of my current joblessness has to do with political stances I took in my work…not my political opinions but my actual policy execution decisions that were a part of my role as a supervisor of social service provision, I did/could not agree with certain types of attitudes and focuses toward “those people” (those with mental illnesses and disabilities). Now I’ve actually got a minor gig with the state and the UofM/rtc training some of those “subversive” ideas/ideals about disability empowerment.
I’m finding a quiet place, reading my (audio) books while building things out of wood with my hands. I’m slowly trying to improve my health and loving and enjoying the time I have left with my wife and daughter. I think often of the friends we made in Ethiopia…believers in Jesus that lived under strong governmental oppression, a dictatorship, and thrived despite the terrible things that their government was capable of. I also comfort myself with the assurance that our nation has gone through some terrible oppressions in the past, that now I can adopt a child of color and that I still have hope for one little immigrant from a tumultuous place who has a forever family and plenty of cuddles and an opportunity for a good education.
There are indeed a lot of disturbing things going on, and I assume it will continue and get worse…but we do have an essential balance of power in this nation…despite the efforts of many to thwart it. I have hope, but I have to look carefully for it…and look away from some sources of anti-hope at the same time. Bonhoeffer’s works from prison would be a good read now, as would Martin Luther King Jr.’s. I have bios of Dorothy Day and Peter Maurin if you’d like to borrow them, incredible encouragement. Reading anything by George MacDonald is good for the soul…even his untranslated Scots stuff…
